Tuesday, November 1, 2016

Denial: Facts are ethical

Roger and I recently saw Denial, the story of holocaust denier David Irving's libel lawsuit against scholar Deborah E. Lipstadt. The movie is worth noting for its ethical core.

Rachel Weisz plays Deborah Lipstadt

Admittedly, there's much to annoy about this movie. Lipstadt's role is not well-scripted, so she comes across as an emotional child-woman (an image reinforced by what was apparently meant to be a 1990s-style permed bob cut but looks more like the wayward curls of a Shirley Temple). As a child-woman and an overly-emotional American, she has to be reined in and schooled by the wiser and more reasoned British (mostly) men on her legal team. The brilliant and morally perfect, as well as avuncular English barrister, Richard Rampton, played by Tom Wilkinson, particularly brings her to gentle heel. While she is not ritually humiliated, for which I give the movie credit, the contrition of her apology once she sees the folly of her ways has an unsettling note of abjection.  

Wilkinson as Rampton gathers the facts at Auschwitz while Lipstadt emotes. Yes the gender stereotypes grate.

In a better movie, we would feel Deborah's outrage and pain at her legal team's strategy. If the movie had been more successful, we as an audience would initially feel she should be able to say her piece in court rather than be muzzled. We would feel that she should, as she would like to do but is forbidden, be able to bring forward Holocaust survivors to prove that Irving is wrong.

In a better movie, the legal team's visit to Auschwitz would pack the emotional punch the filmmakers clearly intended and reinforce our sense that Lipstadt is justified in her righteous anger. Yet it falls flat. That's too bad, because having visited a concentration camp myself (Sachenhausen) I know what a deeply sobering impact such a place can have.

What does work is the film's moral core. There's never any question that Lipstadt is right and Irving wrong, that the Holocaust happened and that denying it is the worst kind of canard. The film makes a convincing, one might even say passionate, ethical case for the use of reason and strategy: winning over evil is far more important than expressing our righteous anger, blasting the truth out or indulging our outrage that a pernicious lie is being treated seriously in a court of law. What matters is winning, not for winning's sake or ego gratification, but so that the lie is smashed, such that that next time it rears up it becomes all the more difficult to tell the lie with any credibility.

The movie shows that to win--to crush the lie of David Irving--it's important to marshall facts, to do hard work and careful research, to keep our emotions, no matter how justified, in check and under control. It is heartening to see in England, at least in this case, a legal system that works, where truth wins and competence matters--and the film shows how important that is. 

Timothy Spall as David Irving. He's shot as a flaccid creep.

The focus on fact seems important to emphasize because we live in a world awash in emotionalism, so much so that one of our Presidential candidates seems to have no control over his twitching, twittering fingers,  a world where personality and "identity" shout down sober reality. As Christoper Hedges put in Truthdig ("American Irrationalism," Nov. 1, 2016):


"Political, intellectual and cultural discourse has been replaced with spectacle. Emotionalism and sensationalism are prized over truth." 

Agreed. While the alt-right or the Neo-Nazis might hope to reduce the holocaust's truth to whatever side can act more aggrieved, be more snide or derisive, or shout louder, to win because their "narrative"  gains "traction" in cyberspace, in fact, the movie says,  documenting the truth is how we defeat evil.

That may be an old-fashioned worldview, but it also the foundation of scholarship--that the careful compilation of verifiable facts matters--and truth is the foundation of democracy. It's also the foundation of the good life: we cannot prosper if we rush into wars or economic policies that are based on blatant fantasies.

The movie also does a good job of exposing Irving for the mocking racist, misogynist and anti-Semite he is. I was startled at his similarities to Trump in what were restagings of speeches he gave. He was also remarkably like Trump in his inability to live in reality: he immediately "spun" his resounding defeat in court as a victory. Well, why not, if facts don't count?

While I value emotion, I long for a society in which its importance is subordinated to truth.  Denial, though a flawed film, provides a decent template for how we can achieve that. 

11 comments:

  1. This is a superb blog and I wish it had more circulation -- especially among feminists (if there are any left). While I admire Rachel Weisz's work enormously, I know that often in films she features in she is presented as a child-woman. She has her heart and reason in the right place, but she is over-emotional, displays very risky behavior (for which she is brutally murdered in The Constant Gardiner). I saw a goddawful movie just recently where this stereotype packaging was to the fore. It's telling to me that you can find better treatment of her, and the two times I know of are films where there is a female community or overt feminism. In the first she had Helen Mirren's Prime Suspect tradition to fall back on:

    https://ellenandjim.wordpress.com/2012/04/12/whistleblower-the-difference-class-makes/

    In the second she was Agora; though there the child-woman type emerged and she dies at the end, the theme of the importance of speech, of teaching was inspiringly done:

    https://ellenandjim.wordpress.com/2010/08/10/agora-the-story-of-a-heroine-as-tragically-silenced-teacher/

    On the issue of campaigns as no longer presenting reason, and wiping away documentation (or hiding it, or suing to keep it out of the public eye), there has been so much said of late, and all to little purpose. I want to say that democracy is badly flawed where a people are so ill-informed and continually subject to propaganda. In the Trump-Clinton campaign an ugly misogyny also fuels the hatred of Clinton, and the repeated public humiliations of her seem never to come to an end. What will happen if she should win the presidency? Like Obama, will a critical number of elected officials simply refuse to acknowledge her as president.

    It's also important to use power against power: the power of a lawyer,k of the courts. I have in front of me a letter asking for money from the Southern Poverty Law Center on the basis of death threats to members of their central teams. They carry on doing the kind of work the film praises.

    As to the exemplary patriarchal male that Wilkinson (think of Bella) is now chosen for, I await a movie where Lily James turns up as his princess-style raped daughter.

    Ellen

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have been married with my wife for 6 years and recently she broke up with me and it hurt me deeply when she told me to leave her alone and that she does not love me anymore when i was always faithful and honest to her. I tried all the ways to get her back buying her what she wants like i always did and she still left me heart broken and she even has a new boyfriend which destroyed me even more until a friend of mine from high school directed me to Dr Emu. This man changed my life completely. I followed everything he told me to do and my wife came back. I was stunned everything happened exactly like he told me. I had faith in everything he told me and everything was true. You can contact him via email: Emutemple@gmail.com He will help you in anything you need and quick to answer once you contact him through his whats-app number: +2347012841542
      For more destails about Dr Emu you can visit his Website: http://emutemple.website2.me/

      Delete
    2. I am by name Miss jane ,And i am so happy to testify about a great spell caster that helped me when all hope was lost for me to unite with my ex-boyfriend that I love so much. I had a boyfriend that love me so much but something terrible happen to our relationship one afternoon when his friend that was always trying to get to me was trying to force me to make love to him just because he was been jealous of his friend that i was dating and on the scene my boyfriend just walk in and he thought we had something special doing together, i tried to explain things to him that his friend always do this whenever he is not with me and i always refuse him but i never told him because i did not want the both of them to be enemies to each other but he never believed me. he broke up with me and I tried times without numbers to make him believe me but he never believed me until one day i heard about the DR. AKHERE and I emailed him and he replied to me so kindly and helped me get back my lovely relationship that was already gone for two months. Email him at: AKHERETEMPLE@gmail.com or call / whatsapp: +2349057261346

      Delete
  2. Beautifully written blog -- I'd just like to know a bit more about Deborah E. Lipstadt. I read the reviews of the film and thought I would pass but may now reconsider. I rarely go to see any films these days as there is so little to choose from. The stereotyping is atrocious. We desperately need some new female role models. Perhaps this will come to pass if Hilary wins the election.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ellen and Elaine,
    Thank you. Ellen, I had not thought of the Southern Poverty Law Center but they are people doing this kind of good work. Elaine, the film is not perfect, but worth seeing.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Roger mentioned the movie Hannah Arendt, that focuses on the Eichmann trial, as a good counterpoint or film to pair with this one. In Hannah Arendt, Arendt is portrayed as a competent, intelligent and fully middle-aged woman, not a girl child. It's an excellent film but should get a shout out for being able to portray an intelligent woman in a non-demeaning way.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I wanted to see this movie when it was in town, but had to miss it. I'm glad to be reminded just now to put it on my list of films to track down. And also Hannah Arendt, which I have never seen. I have seen Rachel Weisz 3 times: Hannah & Her Sisters, Page 8 Masterpiece or Mystery tv film, & most recently in the one about Queen Anne (title won't come to me this morning). She was memorable to me in all those roles & I always enjoy watching Tom Wilkinson & Timothy Spall, so I look forward to seeing Denial somehow. Since the above comment in 2016 we have learned that all was not well at the Southern Poverty Law Center. I hope it is recovering from the dreadful blow to its standing & great reputation. Thank you for this blog, Diane, & the others which I am just reading. Judith

    ReplyDelete
  6. On a lovely summer day in 1960, with 2 other American college students, I went to Dachau, as we had decided we must witness it. We were shaken & moved to our cores by the darkness of the world we saw, & there could be no denial in Dachau's inhuman environs. Back in America soon after, I saw the film of the camp liberations of barely living human beings & the stacks of hundreds of skeletal corpses. No eyes or tongues could deny the Holocaust having seen that film. Over the years, I have met survivors, & children of survivors. The things they've said are the Truth of it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi everyone, my name is Abbie Moore, am from the United States . I want to share my wonderful testimony how I got back my husband back, who I sworn ever to be with until when he left me to another woman for no reason and I try to make things work for both of us yet things where getting worse and I love him so much and there is nothing I could do to get my husband back until I saw a testimony share by a woman called Lauren from Australia on the internet talking about a powerful spell caster called DR. WALE, who brought her husband back within 24hours, so I decide to give it a try and to my greatest surprise he also did it for me just as he did for Lauren and I have a lot of people complaining of fake spell caster but this one I met was a real spell caster who help me to solve my problem I have no solution to, I introduce many of my best friends that have a similar problems, and their problem were solve with the great help of DR. WALE, who help them to get back their lovers within 24 hours. I am so happy that my husband is back to me again, and the most surprising thing is that our love is very strong, every day is happiness and joy. and there is nothing like been with the man you love. I am so happy my love is back to me with the help of DR. WALE. if you have similar problem I will advice you to contact him, he is there to help you and put a smile on your face as he did to me and others you can also WhatsApp him +1(978) 406-9575 or Email him at : everlastingspellcast@gmail.com or view his website for more review https://everlastingspellcaster.website2.me/contact

    ReplyDelete
  8. I am by name Miss jane ,And i am so happy to testify about a great spell caster that helped me when all hope was lost for me to unite with my ex-boyfriend that I love so much. I had a boyfriend that love me so much but something terrible happen to our relationship one afternoon when his friend that was always trying to get to me was trying to force me to make love to him just because he was been jealous of his friend that i was dating and on the scene my boyfriend just walk in and he thought we had something special doing together, i tried to explain things to him that his friend always do this whenever he is not with me and i always refuse him but i never told him because i did not want the both of them to be enemies to each other but he never believed me. he broke up with me and I tried times without numbers to make him believe me but he never believed me until one day i heard about the DR. AKHERE and I emailed him and he replied to me so kindly and helped me get back my lovely relationship that was already gone for two months. Email him at: AKHERETEMPLE@gmail.com or call / whatsapp: +2349057261346

    ReplyDelete
  9. I never thought that there will be a miracle on the internet until i came in contact with Priest Babaka, finally i made it with his help, with his spiritual power which was recommended by a lady in baby center he help before, i never believe it was real until i confirm it now because i have tried so many things to make sure i get pregnant but no luck, immediately i contact him. he did some spiritual prayers and send me a medicine which i took, i got pregnant three weeks after, and i now have a son to show. thank you so much priest and i recommend Priest Babaka for everyone out there that is willing to have a child of her own out there. contact him for help too he is real and powerful, i have confirmed it, contact him on email: babaka.wolf@gmail.com or Facebook at priest.babaka

    ReplyDelete